Ask500

| Login

Should it be against the Law to criticize a religion? Ask a Question

Should it be against the Law to criticize a religion?
Click to vote
Yes
No
5 Answers

Outlaw free speech? I think not!

2 Replies to CDog's answer

It appears as though the Canadian Islamic Congress are trying to label these articles as a promotion of hate as opposed to freedom of expression. It will be interesting to see the outcome. MacLean's Magazine would like to see the copmplaints go to the Supreme Court of Canada and be shot down.

Then it is time to repeal the laws against hate speech. Words are words. Stick and stones. I had a bad feeling when they tried to label hate speech as undeserving of the protections of free speech in the first place.

Oh boy. We're in trouble now.

This comment was deleted.

This comment was deleted.

I wish some of the people who responded yes would explain their decision.

3 Replies to CDog's answer

Interesting.

I just watched a 2 hour special about Jimmy Carter and his book on Palestine. The right-wing/conservative/unconditionally pro-Israel critics (who, according to the film maker, were also the most extreme in their speech) pretty much refused to sign consents for the film.

I can play "devil's advocate".

Islam is deeply important to a Muslim and to attack Islam is an outrage, like attacking a man's mother. One has to defend Islam or they are not worthy of God's blessings but deserve his wrath. There is no reason to speak against religion and cause the discomfort to the listener. Smoking is banned in public places and so should words that are noxious to others.

How did I do? (That was harder than I thought.)

I think you did well, but that point of view claims extra privileges for that group that they will not grant to others. All points of view must be allowed, as long as they are expressed only with words.