Ask500

| Login

Do you think that America should stop using 9/11 as blackmail against Muslims? Ask a Question

5 Answers

This comment was deleted.

17 Replies to deleted user's answer

It happens everyday in other countries buddy. It's not all about America all the time, think about the rest of the world, and im sorry if this offends anyone but it's my opinion and it's correct too.

This comment was deleted.

This comment was deleted by NadiaDarbane4ever .

This comment was deleted.

and being 7 when 9/11 happened,I'm sure gives you a very clear perspective and understanding of what that day was like.

This comment has been moderated down. (Show Comment)

oh no shes 28 now. what is it are you 28 or 15.

Your credibility is shrinking now that we know you lie.

This comment has been moderated down. (Show Comment)

yes you are so right!

Please Duaguy this is the typical left wing nut case attitude about 9/11.At least I actually discussed my thought about this question. Instead of just basically insulting anyone with a different opinion.

And not to mention I think the answers given to choose from are a little biased.lets see I can choose.

1)Yes Americans should get over that it happened 8 years ago- Some how I'm supposed to assume that Americans have not gotten over 9/11 yet.I think we've shown were capable of getting over it,but is this really implying that we should forget about it.

2)No, its they're fault and they're going to pay.-OK so if I pick this one now I'm an ass who assumes all Muslims are guilty for and should be "blackmailed" for 9/11.

3)Does it really matter? Let's just focus on now and move forward.Now this one is sort of correct I think we have moved forward,but I do think what happened on 9/11 still matters.As long as there is still group(s) of people out there that want to,and are willing to kill people like you and me in large numbers for no good reason.9/11 should still matter.

And I'm a little put of buy the assumption that if I care about my own country's security,some how I'm oblivious to the fact that it happens else where.As well as being unsympathetic for those in other country's that this happens to.

I happen to agree with peterf "I see no blackmail. What I do see is a real threat to all countries, not just the US, from Islamic terrorism".I don't see how that's a comment that someone can disagree with.Fundamentalist Islamic terrorist are a real threat to all nation's.

Just because tragedy happens every day in other countries does not make it any easier to forget the tragedy that happened to us. Many of us lost love ones that day, and we all lost the feeling of security that we used to have. We were shocked by the reality of a dangerous world--a reality that we had never witnessed on American soil. We discovered that day that there are people who wish to kill us for no other reason than where we were born, and that they have the capabilities to do so. No American alive that day will ever be able to forget or "get over" what happened.

But should we just cry about what happened to us and do nothing for those who suffer in other places? Of course not. We should always be striving to end suffering around the world. All people should be able to have the same feeling of security that we have here in the US, and we should be working hard to make it happen. We have learned what it's like to feel afraid, and we never want to feel that again. This is why we feel for those who suffer more than we could imagine, and this is why we need to end it.

This comment has been moderated down. (Show Comment)

As you can see from the discussion at this point, the concept that Islamic terrorism is a natural and expected (EVERY administration since Reagan has been told that their actions would INCREASE terrorism, not decrease it) result of Western (including American) policies in the Middle East since the time of the British, combined with the destruction of the secular Arab political base, is far beyond what most Americans are willing to consider as a factor in Islamic actions.

This comment was deleted.

This comment has been moderated down. (Show Comment)

This comment was deleted.

This comment has been moderated down. (Show Comment)

maybe the terrorist who happen to be Muslims, should stop blackmailing the US with more attacks that would be greater than 9/11.And it happens to be the job of the government to protect its people from foreign threats.

I see no blackmail. What I do see is a real threat to all countries, not just the US, from Islamic terrorism.

1 Replies to peterf's answer

This comment has been moderated down. (Show Comment)

I am very offended by the fact that you say Americans use 9/11 against Muslims. You make it sound like we are all bigots who hate Muslims because of an attack that went against all of the values that real Muslims hold dear. Most Americans find judging someone based upon their religion to be a disgusting practice, especially judgement against Muslims because of the hatred that some people expressed toward them during the heightened emotional time in the days after 9/11. I remember shortly after that how people began educating themselves about Islam. People were researching it on the internet, learning the truth about the religion, and they were reaching out to Muslims in their communities. People went out of their way to show that they did not hate those who practiced Islam.

There has always been a central tenant to American society: Diversity. In the US, we take pride in the fact that not everyone is the same color. We take pride in the fact that not everyone believes the same thing. We take pride in the idea that we can be who we are without having to fear retribution from others.

Of course, you will always have your nut jobs, those who hate based on skin color, gender, religion, and sexual orientation, but for every person who hates, you will find ten more who love. Never believe that the actions of a few stupid people represent the beliefs of an entire nation. No matter where you go, you will find someone ready to be your friend, ready to help you, ready even to defend you from those who attack you. Never forget that.

14 Replies to Jamin's answer

This comment was deleted.

First off, I didn't vote for him.

And second, Bush didn't run on the platform of "vote for me if you hate Muslims." He ran on a platform of fear. He basically told Americans that Kerry would not keep them safe, and over half of the country believed him. No one (or at least almost no one...there are always nut jobs) elected him out of hate for Muslims...if you believe that, you would be the uneducated one.

This comment was deleted.

Not many Americans had the news the way the Europeans did. Their news is made so they can sell advertising slots. The news stations want to please the advertisers and care more for what people want to hear, then fact. Fox even went to court claiming they have the right "to make up the news as they see fit". Americans made their judgment on the information they had, they are as tolerant as any other people, however the were not served well by their "free" press.

This comment was deleted.

America is a huge country largely isolated from external influences. It has nothing to do with the intelligence of the average American. They are told America is the best country in the world, just like every citizen of any country. Most Europeans do get news stations from other countries (including the USA) And to be fair to my neighbors in the south, I am actually surprised how well some Americans are informed despite their news channels.

This comment was deleted.

You could argue that the downturn in the economy was the straw that broke the camel's back. So the argument could be made that the people were just as simple-minded and self-centered as they were during the 2004 elections. However, they did pick the better of the two candidates in my opinion.

Lol, just realized I used an idiom that originated in the middle east.

This comment was deleted.

I totally agree, I think most people in the world are very pleased to see a change of course.

This comment was deleted.

Maybe the individuals don't, but the government did.

Very well put Jamin. This question is at its best "very badly phrased". It carries in an assumption. Therefore it is not an open question and I refuse to answer it. Of course it is very bad to blame muslims in general for what happened on 9/11 and I do not have the impression that most Americans are doing so. I do blame the terrorists that committed those acts, as well as I blame a lot of western and Arab leaders that helped feed radical islam.

Look, the vast majority of Muslims aren't involved in terrorist activity. I don't care how much time passes, I'll never forget how I felt the day those planes crashed into the towers and the Pentagon. But projecting our fear and anxiety on people at random, just because they share the same religion as people who committed those crimes is wrong and I refuse to engage in it. I have faith that most Americans are too intelligent to assume that because someone looks a certain way or holds certain religious beliefs that he or she must be a terrorist. For those who engage in hatemongering and playing the blame game with the Muslim world, well, shame on you. Now keep it to yourself, because I don't want anymore of your ridiculous email forwards or your racist jokes. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.

1 Replies to asletson9's answer

This comment was deleted.