Canadians: Western Canadians should begin to explore the idea of forming their own country
Click to vote
16%78 Votes
Strongly Disagree
15%74 Votes
Disagree
15%72 Votes
Undecided
17%82 Votes
Agree
36%172 Votes
Strongly Agree
16%78 Votes
Strongly Disagree
15%74 Votes
Disagree
15%72 Votes
Undecided
17%82 Votes
Agree
36%172 Votes
Strongly Agree
Male
Female
15%20 Votes
Strongly Disagree
30%39 Votes
Disagree
27%35 Votes
Undecided
15%20 Votes
Agree
12%16 Votes
Strongly Agree
Results by Country
Results by Voter Type
Community votes are collected from you and other visitors to Ask500People. Independent votes are collected from visitors to hundreds of other websites around the world.
Sign Up or Login
Sorry, this data is only available to users with an account.
The Bloc-NDP-Liberal coalition government has strongly upset at least some Western Canadians. Proposals for cabinet positions do not include any Albertans. In 2005, fully 35.6 per cent of Westerners agreed with the idea of thinking about separating from Canada. We're curious if that number is higher or lower now.
well i hope not. after all isn't that why we vote?western Canadians need to hang in there and fight for their country threw the polls.you cant just give up and take your ball away when when the score doesn't go your way.
Well... Maybe you haven't been following the news in Canada. Here's a short summary: Conservatives won (with a Westerner, Stephen Harper, as minority PM). Now three parties are planning to oust Harper via a coalition government with the separatist Bloc Quebecois, the socialist NDP, and the Liberals, without an election. Some are calling it a coup. There is hardly anyone from out West who would get into Cabinet (Ralph Goodale is the sole exception right now).
[4 points]3 years ago by peterjaworskiReplyEdited 3 years ago by peterjaworski
well your right i haven't been following Canadian politics.And what you just told me sounds like a raw deal.Maybe the threat of some drastic measures like succeeding will help change things.maybe it isn't a good idea to have more than a 2 party government?
The conservatives have the largest number of seats of the four major parties (they got 35% of the popular vote), they do not have the majority of the seats though. The reason the other three got upset was because the conservatives did not play nice and are bringing the country from a healthy surplus into a deficit while failing to deal with the economic problems. Some measure was put into a bill that all three opposition parties were very upset about, they got together and good luck trying to split them up now.
In any case There will be a new election called in the spring and whoever is blamed for the problems will get into trouble, so expect a lot of blame going back and forth....
Those backwards conservatives! they should have no voice in the government what so ever! hey that multi party system really sounds like its working only 1/3 of the country wants to separate.
Why?
http://westernstandard.blogs.com/shotgun/2008/12/ws-poll-western.html
The Bloc-NDP-Liberal coalition government has strongly upset at least some Western Canadians. Proposals for cabinet positions do not include any Albertans. In 2005, fully 35.6 per cent of Westerners agreed with the idea of thinking about separating from Canada. We're curious if that number is higher or lower now.
This comment was deleted.
[2 points] 3 years ago by deleted user Replywell i hope not. after all isn't that why we vote?western Canadians need to hang in there and fight for their country threw the polls.you cant just give up and take your ball away when when the score doesn't go your way.
Well... Maybe you haven't been following the news in Canada. Here's a short summary: Conservatives won (with a Westerner, Stephen Harper, as minority PM). Now three parties are planning to oust Harper via a coalition government with the separatist Bloc Quebecois, the socialist NDP, and the Liberals, without an election. Some are calling it a coup. There is hardly anyone from out West who would get into Cabinet (Ralph Goodale is the sole exception right now).
well your right i haven't been following Canadian politics.And what you just told me sounds like a raw deal.Maybe the threat of some drastic measures like succeeding will help change things.maybe it isn't a good idea to have more than a 2 party government?
This comment was deleted.
[3 points] 3 years ago by deleted user ReplyThe conservatives have the largest number of seats of the four major parties (they got 35% of the popular vote), they do not have the majority of the seats though. The reason the other three got upset was because the conservatives did not play nice and are bringing the country from a healthy surplus into a deficit while failing to deal with the economic problems. Some measure was put into a bill that all three opposition parties were very upset about, they got together and good luck trying to split them up now.
In any case There will be a new election called in the spring and whoever is blamed for the problems will get into trouble, so expect a lot of blame going back and forth....
Those backwards conservatives! they should have no voice in the government what so ever! hey that multi party system really sounds like its working only 1/3 of the country wants to separate.
This comment was deleted.
[1 point] 3 years ago by deleted user Replynot surprised.
This comment was deleted.
[2 points] 3 years ago by deleted user Replyno at your inability to understand a rational point. ha
This comment was deleted.
[2 points] 3 years ago by deleted user Replyits not my fault you don't understand sarcasm.
This comment was deleted.
[0 points] 3 years ago by deleted user ReplyThis comment was deleted by jave01 .
[1 point] 3 years ago byIf the Quebecois can't make a success of seceding, then the Western provinces don't have a chance.
Quebec has a completely different language and culture than the rest of Canada. If they haven't seceded, I don't see how other provinces can.